Ethical Challenges of the War in Afghanistan Essay

Ethics Paper Ethical Challenges of the War in Afghanistan After ten years of fighting in Afghanistan and Iraq, military leaders still face significant ethical challenges. Because of the challenges associated with waging an unconventional war, military practices and preparations have not evolved to provide sufficient ethical training for personnel in Afghanistan and Iraqi. This essay explores ethical questions that remain unresolved even after a war that has been prosecuted for more than a decade. Unresolved Ethical Issues Many ethical issues related to warfare, conventional and otherwise, have never been resolved. For example, there is a widely held belief that all people have a basic, prima facie right not to be killed. Even so,†¦show more content†¦That same rage which keeps them alive in combat also makes them unlikely to show mercy to civilians or enemy Soldiers who may surrender in combat. Perry argues that Soldiers need not be encouraged to hate the enemy in order for them to be effective in combat situations. He further argues that Soldiers must be â€Å"allowed and encouraged to disobey immoral orders† (Perry, 2004). With respect to police actions, the question arises as to how serious must a government’s abuse of its citizens’ human rights be before other countries are justified in intervening militarily. Another ethical issue arises with respect to treatment of suspected Al Qaeda members who are known to kill noncombatants indiscriminately: should they be treated as criminal suspects, or as prisoners of war, or as something else? In addition, under what circumstances does rigorous interrogation of suspected terrorists equate to torture? Is torturing suspected terrorists morally justified to prevent mass murder? In theory, the answer is yes, because a known terrorist has forfeited his right to not be tortured. In reality though, this practice risks the torture of innocent people given that the interrogator may lack sufficient evidence to know that the suspect is guilty. A closely related issue arises if the U.S. as a nation trains or authorizes Soldiers to torture; then moral ly they cannot be distinguishedShow MoreRelatedWomen And Girls s Rights1565 Words   |  7 Pages Title - Women and girls fight for their right to education in Afghanistan Background and Rationale The topic that I have chosen for my dissertation is women and girls educational rights in Afghanistan. The topic’s focus derives from the abandoning of female rights in Afghanistan due to the political significance of the war against the Taliban in 2001. Decades of conflict in Afghanistan, under the Taliban regime destroyed the educational system and female rights. The Taliban are a group of fundamentalistRead MoreThe United States Military Operations1694 Words   |  7 PagesUnited State (U.S) in Afghanistan was not justified considering soldiers and civilian’s causalities, the waste of time and equally so the mismanagement of resources. As a result, there are stupendous argument or proof to support these facts contradictorily; there are even stronger and amazing points of view that support the justifications of military presence by the U.S. in Afghanistan. The main reasons for the military operation by the U.S. in Afghanistan were to fight the â€Å"war on terrorâ⠂¬  and to weakeningRead MoreThe Military Of The Army Today1283 Words   |  6 PagesAbstract In the Army today, we have dealt with many difficult complex challenges that put our nation in a difficult situation with the rest of the world and our troops. As American soldiers we are accountable for meeting certain standards and expectations in most of every mission we are given to accomplish. Desertion in our military takes away our motivation, inspiration Army values, beliefs expressed in code and creed, and is embedded within our unique Army culture for each of us to perform ourRead MoreEthical Norms Of The United Convention1577 Words   |  7 Pagesfrom the day we born and we use them on a daily basis. Ethical norms start from families, kindergarden, school, and work. They are different in religions, in cultures, in societies, and in different countries, but in their roots, they are the same. The laws copied from ethics are natural laws. During war we kill and torture people which is considered to be unethical but, there are some issues that we accept things which we donà ¢â‚¬â„¢t have to. War has always been and will continue to be a necessary actionRead MoreEssay On Ethics In War1135 Words   |  5 PagesTechnologies and Ethics in War Technologies of Precision Guided Munitions have been put forward by some scholars and government as ethical solutions the challenges of killing non-combatants in military operations. USA Presidents Bush and Obama both praised these technologies as having reduced significantly the number of casualties. Professor Maja Zehfuss (2011: PP543-556) critique of targeting with Precision Munitions raises several issues that question the confidence placed in the technologiesRead MoreMichael Moore s Fahrenheit 9 / 111450 Words   |  6 Pagesthe handling of the â€Å"war on terror.† Moore stresses the questionable ethical nature of the post-9/11 policies put in place by the Bush administration, particularly as they give a new meaning to the U.S. relationship between censorship and freedom. In this manner, the documentary challenges the Bush’s administration construction of America’s morality as self-serving and ultimately elitist. The film contends that Americans were deceived during the push for war with Afghanistan and Iraq since no weaponsRead MoreA Historical Event Involving An Ethical Challenge Essay1327 Words   |  6 PagesIntroduction War has always been a terrible affair between societies. It can bring out the very best and the very worse in human beings. Whether it brings out the best or the worse in an individual soldier depends greatly on how their leaders or their society conditioned them beforehand. This has inspired the U.S. Army to emphasize character development prior to a unit’s deployment as a means of preparing soldiers for ethical challenges and to ensure that those soldiers demonstrate behaviors thatRead MoreU.s. Department Of Homeland Security1261 Words   |  6 Pagespreparedness of our nation’s emergency response professionals, provide the federal government’s response, aid America’s recovery from terrorist attacks and natural disasters and foresight. War on Terrorism â€Å"War on terror is a misnomer. It would be like calling America’s involvement in World War II a â€Å"war on kamikazism.† Terrorism, like kamikazism, is a tactic,† Dinesh D’Souza, an Indian public speaker once noted. It goes without saying that terrorist actions do not appear suddenly, by someone’sRead MoreAnalysis Of The Film Terraferma1190 Words   |  5 Pagesthe moral and ethical imperative to relieve suffering, can have discriminatory and even violent consequences in the absence of guiding political principles and practices† ( 2006; 2). Sadly enough, Filippo had to escape as well in order to help the family reach safety. The Italian film is very interesting because it demonstrates that sometimes people are not able to help asylum seekers regardless of their ethical ideals. The main idea of the film is to demonstrate the challenges that ItalianRead MoreThe Effects Of War On The Environment1223 Words   |  5 Pagesresearch. What is war? What are the different types of conflicts that can be classified as war? What is your country or origin? Has your country experienced or engaged in war since 1960s? What are the general effects of war on the environment? What do think are the effects of modern war and military activities on biodiversity? How does war affect the ecosystem? What are the effects of war on human beings and other animals? Do you think the nuclear bombs and other chemicals used during war affect the environment